Friday, August 31, 2007

Batsbi Fraternization, Marriage, and Traditional Justice

-
The aliens in Tsova Tusheti [i.e. non-Batsbi strangers, individuals or families from other regions having settled among the Batsbis in Tsovata/Tsova Tusheti from neighbouring Khevsureti or Chechnya, for example] were frequently those seeking to escape blood feuds. They were accepted in the Batsbi community on certain conditions, and after a period of several years’ observation the host Batsbi village or community would collectively decide upon the status of the new arrivals, and upon the issue of their official assimilation into their host, Batsbi community. This assimilation can be described as a form of adoption, of fraternization, whereby strangers would be officially adopted by a Batsbi family or extended family, taking their name, and becoming full (and to a large extent equal) members of their adoptive community, with the same rights and obligations as all the other family members.

This official adoption would follow a precise ritual, which was to be performed in the “Sameba” (“Holy Trinity”) church [in Tsovata?] during the Whitsunday holidays, in which all the Batsbi villages took part. The stranger who was to be adopted [i.e. an individual migrant or the head of a family] would sacrifice a white bull to the church, and sacred beer would be brewed in the church, and all concerned and attendant would join in a great feast. After this ritual, a newcomer would be considered as a member of a particular Batsbi family, as full “blood brother” and kin, and would be under the protection of his adoptive family. This ritual being dependent upon the collective decision of the stranger’s host community, following several years’ observation, it stands to reason that in some cases the hosts would decide not to accept a stranger’s claim to fraternization, and, consequently, the ritual would not be held and the newcomers would be banished.

In the early twentieth century, among the Batsbis living in Zemo Alvani in the Kakhetian lowlands, a foreign herdsman by the name of Baramidze sought to become related to the local [Batsbi] Mikeladze family. The corresponding “bull ritual” was held, but, later on, a red stain was discovered on the sacrificed animal’s hide. After this event – which in any case cannot have been very popular with the local Russian administration – such processes of fraternization were stopped, and the bull ritual disappeared.

A White Bull destined to be sacrificed during a peace conference [i.e. fraternization] between the Dinka and Nuer tribes in the Sudan in 1999.

-

Conjugal unity was considered to be sacred – Unfaithfulness was extremely shameful, disgraceful, and would have been an extremely rare occurrence, particularly among such small, mountain communities. Traditional habitual justice provided for severe punishments for rape, adultery, promiscuity, or other forms of extra-marital sexual relationships. A rapist would be executed, and the husband of an unfaithful wife could punish her by disfigurement, such as shaving her head or cutting off her nose or an arm; public indignation would also cause individuals deemed to be at fault to be shunned by the community. However, some ethnographers have stated that bigamy existed among the Batsbis: In marriages where the wife was found to be sterile, after a period of several years she herself would set out to look for another wife for her husband, in order to provide him with an heir.

-

As late as the early twentieth century, Batsbi society was to a large extent regulated through traditional, habitual justice.

For depriving someone of an arm or an eye, the guilty person had to pay 120 bulls. For breaking a tooth, 3 cows. For kidnapping a woman, the punishment would have been excommunication, banishment and exile, or death. Until the twentieth century, ransom for murder or manslaughter was common in Tusheti: A certain sum had to be paid in copper pots or salt [i.e. extremely valuable commodities unobtainable in the region]. If a person guilty of killing someone – whether intentionally or by accident – was unable to pay the decreed ransom, he and his family would have had to flee their home, for he (and his nearest relatives) would have been at risk until the age of 60!

-

This information was taken from Roland Topchishvili's article on the Tsova-Tush/Bats people. Prof. Topchishvili is Professor of Ethnology at the Javakhishvili Institute of History of the Georgian Academy of Sciences, and is a specialist in the ethnography of Georgia and other Caucasian regions.

Batsbi Weaving

-
Here are some pictures relating to Batsbi carpets and felt, cropped from other photographs on this website.
-
- -
-The upper transversal bar of a very large upright loom (see image immediately above)
-

A Batsbi "Nabadi" (pressed felt)

-
A beautiful "buteh" pattern. (See identical carpet in previous post)

-

Thursday, August 30, 2007

Two [Tchaghma-]Tush Weddings in Iliurta

-
-
-
These two photographs here courtesy of the man who runs the museum of Tush history and culture in Kvemo Alvani (in the “kulturis sakhli”, “culture-of house”, on the main square, down the central corridor, fourth door on the left). Ivan(?) kindly let the Author set up his laptop and scanner on the floor and copy these two outstanding photographs in situ, the entire process lasting no more than ten minutes, following which the museum’s guardian had to be repeatedly prompted to accept a small donation for the museum’s upkeep. (The museum is lit by a single lightbulb at the end of several metres of electrical cable; the guardian follows you around as you tour the exhibits, lighting your way.)
-
-
Some details cropped from these two pictures:
-
A Salamuri
-

A Panduri

-

A Doli
-
Two Crosses (with Apples and Eggs, apparently)
-

The Bridal Headdress

-

The Man with the Pistol

-
The Boy with the Wine
-

More Old Photographs

These photographs here courtesy of the Mikeladze sisters, who generously brought out several African carrier bags of old photographs and let me pick out these (and other) pictures to copy them at my leisure during my latest stay in Zemo Alvani (27-30 August). All of the photographs are numbered on the back, and many of them are labelled, as they were destined to be exhibited in a small museum in Zemo Alvani dedicated to Batsbi history and culture, which – alas! – never saw the light of day for lack of funding. The Author was also shown several old examples of traditional Batsbi carpets and some undatable funerary urns, all duly photographed, the photographs being destined to appear on this website very soon.

-




























This photograph was taken as a record of the Batsbi/Tsova-Tush men who fought on the Russian side against the Ottoman Turks during the Russo-Turkish War of 1877-8. Note that many of the Batsbi fighters are still wearing chain-mail! (See also this photograph of two warriors.)

Historically, Batsbi men who left Tsovata to fight – against the Persians down in Kakheti, for example – each left a white stone on a mountain pass close to the source of the Alazani River. (The Batsbis in Tsovata could muster around 500 fighting men, approximately a third of the total population.) When they returned from the war, each man removed a stone; thanks to this system, rapid tallies could be made of how many men left, and of how many returned.
-


Batsbis at a “khati”, a shrine, near the village of Dano in Pirikiti Tusheti (the home of Lela Tataraidze, a famous Georgian singer, described to the Author as “Tusheti’s Jennifer Lopez”.) Note the presence of the sacrificial sheep, and that the “khantsi”, the drinking horns, are linked by a length of chain or string, as are the two beakers in the background.
-
Two Batsbi (or Khevsur?) warriors, wearing chain-mail, and armed with muskets, sabres, daggers, and small shields. The man on the right seems to have chain-mail on his trouser legs as well, or perhaps merely chain-mail kneepads.
-
















Monday, August 27, 2007

Some Bats Links

From "The Red Book of the Peoples of the Russian Empire"
-

From Wikipedia: the Bats people, and the Bats language

-
From the University of Frankfurt's
"ECLING" Project (Endangered Languages in Georgia)
-

From
Ethnologue
-

From the Volkswagen Foundation's
"DOBES" Programme (documentation of endangered languages)
-
From the University of Graz's Languages of the World Server
-
From Roland Topchishvili's Article on the National Parliamentary Library of Georgia Website
-
From the "Europe and North Asia" Chapter of the
Encyclopedia of the world’s endangered languages
-
(Any more submissions would be very gratefully received!)
-

Sunday, August 26, 2007

Caucasian Carpets

Carpets from the Caucasus, scanned from a book:
-
An Azeri "chul" horse-cover from Karabagh. "Since the owner was [clearly] an individual of status, the emphasized motif in the lower right-hand corner may be a tamgha, a symbol of tribal identity, ownership, and authority."
-
-
A beautiful geometric kilim (
probably Azeri):
-
-
A stunning eighteenth-century "Shield Carpet" (also Azeri):
-
-
A rare and particularly-beautiful Kumyk, Avar, or Dargi
dum carpet from Daghestan:
-
-
A "Dragon" Carpet:
-
-
And an early colour photograph of items on display at the "All-Russian Kustar Exhibition" of 1913 (i.e. an exhibition of carpet, weaving, and embroidery as practised under State supervision in Imperial Russia):
- -
-
For more information on carpets and rugs from the Caucasus, please consult this excellent guide.
-
Here you will find a guide and further links to Caucasian Flatweaves ("Kilims"), to rugs from Daghestan, from the Bortchalo ("Marneuli") region of Georgia, from Karabagh, to the so-called "Lori-Pambak" Kazakh rugs, "Dragon" carpets, etc.
-

There are about 5 or 6 carpet shops in Tbilisi. They all have very nice pieces in stock, obviously, old and new, but I think it is fair to say that the "Caucasian Carpets Gallery" i.e. carpet shop owned by Manana Arkania offers the best variety and value for money. They have rugs and kilims from all over Georgia, and a small private collection of kilims from Tusheti (now almost unobtainable) which they will be happy to show. Patima, who runs the shop, speaks English, as does her pretty Mingrelian-Svanetian colleague, who makes some of the best Turkish coffee in Tbilisi! The shop is on Erekle Street - towards the bottom end of Leselidze St., close to the Sioni church and the tacky "luxury" establishments of Chardeni St. (where wealthy Georgians drink French wine...) - and is open daily from 10 to 8.

-

The Batsmobile

-
A picture of "the Batsmobile" - i.e. a Lada Niva 4x4 full of Batsbis - and three of the Road to Tusheti: looking down towards Kakheti from the Abanos Pass; an Abandoned Electrical Pylon on the Pass itself; and looking down towards Tusheti.
-
-

Saturday, August 25, 2007

The Batsbi Wedding

--
This Bats wedding, which took place in Zemo-Alvani in 1893, does not seem to have been a particularly joyous occasion! (At least not for the official portrait - the only smiling face belongs to the little boy striking a pose at the bride's feet.) Note the fierce-looking chap on the right, holding a jug of wine in his hand, and the somewhat nervous-looking woman in European dress to his right.
-
-
And here's the family at home, after the wedding. (Note the beautiful carpet!, apparently a Bats design, and unfortunately in black and white - For more carpets, please click here.)
-
-
The following are details cropped from these two photographs, in no particular order:
-
The Tamada(?) and the Schoolteacher(?)(the only person in European dress)
-
The Warrior
-
A proud-looking Boy
-
Some interesting expressions
-
The Happy Couple, with the Priest and the Bride's (or the Groom's) Mother(?)
-
Some Batsbi Girls (the Girl on the left is stunning)
-
And two Brothers(?)
-

Tuesday, August 14, 2007

Etymological Dictionaries

Have you ever wanted to look up the etymology of a High East Cushitic word? Is the origin of a term in West Central Khoisan still a mystery to you? Are you one of the 0.002 people per day who wonder what the verb "to smear" is in Proto-Lezgi? Do you sometimes ask yourself what the correspondences of Nostratic affricatives are like? Then these databases are for you!

Caucasian Languages - Numbers and Geographical Distribution

-
-
A Table listing the main Caucasian Languages in terms of Number of Speakers and Geographical Distribution (by country).
-
-
And a truly amazing Ethnolinguistic Map of the Caucasus.

(From the excellent Linguarium Website)
-

Sunday, August 12, 2007

Caucasian Dialects

The following are several tables outlining the 123 dialects corresponding to 37 Caucasian languages.










(After Klimov 1994)


Thursday, August 9, 2007

Caucasian Isoglosses


Here follows a table in four parts, table which lists the commonalities of certain words between different Caucasian languages (after G. Klimov 1994).
-
Part 1 English-Avar-Botlikh-Chamalal-Dargi-Georgian-Mingrelian-Laz-Svan



Part 2 Khinalug-Lak-Aghul-Archi-Lezgi-Rutul-Tabassaran-Tsakhur-Udi-Bats


Part 3 Chechen-Ingush-Bezhta-Dido-Hinukh-Hunzib-Adyghe-Kabardian-Ubykh



Part 4 Abkhaz-Abaz-Armenian-Persian-Greek-Syriac-Akkadian

Photographs of Tsovata during Dadaloba


Apologies for the appalling quality of these photographs - The delicate Japanese electronics of my camera didn't like being left out in the rain. (For the full, boring, yet tragic story, please see
this previous post. And for some nicer photographs - courtesy of Pridon Beroshvili at Indurta.com - please click here!)


The Draw to decide who the next "Shulta" Families will be.


The Classic View of Indurta.


A Double Rainbow in the Evening Sky over Jvarboseli.


A young Caucasian Sheepdog in the Tsovatistsqali Valley.


Sheltering from the Sun in Indurta.


The Supra (Feast) for Dadaloba, with the Men's Khati in the Background.


Peto.


The Men's Khati (Church) in Tsovata.


Preparing for the Feast.


Leftovers.


The Women's Khati (Church) in Tsovata.


The Skyline in Tsovata at Dusk.


The Guesthouse in Jvarboseli.


Tusheti as seen from the Abanos Pass.




South Caucasian ("Kartvelian")

The 4 Languages of the South Caucasian or "Kartvelian" (i.e. Georgian) Family.

(North-)West Caucasian


The 5 Languages of the (North-)Western Caucasian Family.

(North-)East Caucasian ("Nakho-Daghestanian")


The 29 Languages of the (North-)Eastern Caucasian (or "Nakho-Daghestanian") Family.

From Jvarboseli to Tsovata by Satellite

The Route from Jvarboseli to Indurta.

Monday, August 6, 2007

A Few Words on the Origins of the Bats People


As their two different names indicate, the Tsova-Tush/Bats are Georgians, sharing all the characteristics of their Georgian neighbours in Tusheti, and yet are profoundly different by virtue of their second, Nakh language (i.e. from the Nakh branch of Caucasian languages - See the language's lineage here.)

There is no definite information as to the origins of the Tsova-Tush/Bats. Most observers can agree upon the fact that they migrated to Tushetia in the mountains of north-eastern Georgia several centuries ago, and that they previously lived in Vainakh lands. ("Vainakh", "our people", i.e. Chechnya or Ingushetia.) This seems to me the most likely theory. A relatively detailed and complete account of the migrations of the Tsova-Tush/Bats people, based upon a story related by an elderly (b.1928) inhabitant of Zemo-Alvani, goes as follows:

"Six shepherds who lived in villages in the Georgian lowlands - one from the village of Matani, at the southern end of the Pankisi Gorge, and the others from the region of Kiziqi - stayed in the Gometsi Gorge of Pshavi [a mountainous region of north-eastern Georgia] for a long time, searching for better pastures for their flocks of sheep. A man named Sveluri joined them in Pshavi, and told them of a certain Jarieri Gorge in Ingushetia, which he said was rich in excellent pastures. The Georgian shepherds, interested by his account of this distant gorge, moved there with their flocks and families, and settled in Ingushetia permanently. Years later, they began to intermarry with the local Ingush people, and the Ingush language [like Chechen, a Nakh language] naturally became the native tongue of their descendants. After having lived in Ingushetia for a long time, the successors of the Georgian migrants were forced to leave their village and seek out a new home and new pastures. [The Tsova-Tush/Bats claim to this day that their ancestors were forced to leave Ingushetia/Chechnya to escape forced conversion to Islam; an Ingush narrative accounts for their departure on grounds of a dispute over pasture property-rights.] They left Ingushetia and spent several years wandering from place to place in Chechnya, then in Tianetia [another mountainous region of north-eastern Georgia], finally settling in the villages of Chontio, Girevi, and Hegho in northern Tushetia [in Pirikiti Tushetia]. After several years there, they moved to the nearby Tsovatsqali Valley, which became "Tsovata", the homeland of the Tsova-Tush/Bats people."
--------------------------------

This information was taken from Roland Topchishvili's article on the Tsova-Tush/Bats people. Prof. Topchishvili is Professor of Ethnology at the Javakhishvili Institute of History of the Georgian Academy of Sciences, and is a specialist in the ethnography of Georgia and other Caucasian regions.

Saturday, August 4, 2007

Some Photographs of Tsovata during Dadaloba








Preparing Cheese
-
Preparing "Khashlama" (boiled mutton - yum!)
-
Hangover, Alcohol, and a Cigarette - A Typical Tsovata Breakfast Scene
-